In health, we're handed a mountain of information and advice, and a lot of it contradicts itself. That's a paradox: a statement or situation that seems contradictory or illogical, but that contains a hidden truth one you look closer.
​
​The point of a paradox isn't to solve it. It's to sit with it. Think of it like a koan, the Zen Buddhist meditation device used to encourage direct experience of reality. We're not trying to get too deep here, but we are going to use these paradoxes to think critically about our beliefs about health.
​
​When you embrace a paradox instead of fighting it, it relieves the pressure to find "the one right answer." It validates confusion. It opens up space for personal discernment and exploration.
​
​We want health to be straightforward, and it's often presented that way. But that's not how it works as the individual level. It requires holding opposing ideas at the same time and still moving forward.
​
​F. Scott Fitzgerald put it best: "The test of first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposing ideas in mind at the same time and still retain the ability to function." And we're all pretty intelligent, right?

Contradicting ideas aren't new. You may already be familiar with a few:

On the surface these seem impossible. But look a little deeper at lifestyle factors,  healthcare systems, socioeconomic conditions, stress, and social determinants of health, and the pieces start to make sense. We can reason those out and land somewhere comfortable.
​
​The next six paradoxes are trickier. They hit close to home, and they don't resolve with a quick explanation. They require personal reflection and lived experience.

Tracking our health can separate us from our bodies, but it's also how we learn about them.
​
​We can track almost everything now: step, sleep, labs, macros, micros, bone density, longevity markers. We're living in an era of unprecedented access to out body's inner workings, and that's genuinely great. It gives us insight. It puts us in the driver's seat. It prioritizes prevention.
​
​But all that data comes at a cost like false positives, unnecessary procedures, the literal price tag, and all the anxiety of watching the numbers. Striving for a "perfect score" can actually make things worse and we lose sight of why we starting tracking in the first place.
​
​A perfect sleep score isn't the point. Feeling better and having more energy is the point. Some mornings you wake up feeling great, check your sleep score, see it's low, and suddenly feel tired. The number talked you out of your own lived experience.
​
​Awareness matters, but too much of it creates its own paradox: you need it, but too much creates overwhelm. You can't be aware of everything or solve every problem at once. This is where intention comes in.

Track intentionally. Data is only useful if you plan to act on it. Its whole job is to inform your actions. Narrow your focus to one area at a time: better sleep, more energy, more strength. Don't put too much weight on a single data point; watch the trend instead.

Where you land on tracking is personal. For some people, more data is calming. It creates a sense of control. For others, it's a source of anxiety. Know where you fall, because it's not binary.

There's a real cost to getting this wrong. Picture someone who was once a diehard step-tracker, walking laps around the living room five minutes before bed just to hit the arbitrary 10,000 - completely missing the point of tracking steps in the first place, which was to move more throughout the day. Sometimes the fix isn't better data, it's less visible data: a faceless wristband that nudges you to get up, without numbers taunting you all day. Enough friction to keep the obsession at bay.

Once you've lost sight of why you started tracking, you've gone too far. It's time to reevaluate. If your mood starts rising and falling with the numbers, or your self-worth gets tangled up in the results, the method (or tracking itself) may not be for you. And remember: tracking doesn't have to be permanent. You can take it or leave it whenever it suits you.

Everything counts, but not everything matters.
​
​"This cake doesn't count, it's my birthday." "I don't need to go to bed on time, it's the weekend." "20 minutes isn't long enough to count as a workout."
​
​Let's get one thing straight: it all counts. The single squat you did this morning, the candy from your coworkers desk, the yard work, the veggies in your smoothie, the heavy wine pour on Saturday. It all counts.
​
​But it can't all matter. You get to decide what matters to you.
​
​Our needs change over time. Something can be well-intentioned and still no longer serve you. We all carry unexamined beliefs that keep us doing things that aren't aligned with who we are now, or who we're trying to become.
​
​To work through this paradox, do an honest audit: does your "it counts" list actually line up with your "what matters" list? You might find you're not giving yourself enough credit for the things that truly matter and spending way too much energy counting the things that don't.

Sometimes the most effective change comes from doing less, not more.
​
​Our default is to add rather than subtract. And there's research to back it up. In the well-known Lego Tower Experiment, participants were given an unstable structure and told to make it stable. The overwhelming majority added a block instead of removing it, even after being told extra blocks would cost money. Granted, it was only 10 cents, but it does mirror real like, where most additive solutions cost something.
​
​We gravitate toward "more" for a few reasons. There's a "more is better" mentality that may be an evolutionary holdover from scarcer times, when vigilance about having enough was survival. Now, more is almost always a click away. Subtraction also just takes more cognitive effort. It's harder to picture the result of removing something, especially when you're stressed, rushed, or distracted (so, basically always). It's simpler for our brains to reach for something to add.
​
​So, ask yourself: what could you stop doing, or stop forcing? If something feels incredibly hard, that might be the signal it's time to do less, not more.

Just because it's the "right" thing to do doesn't mean it's the right thing for you.
​
​There's no shortage of health, wellness, and nutrition research out there. Enough that with a little digging, you can find a study to support any position.
​
​Take strength training. Research on women and strength training is finally growing, and that's fantastics. Women have been famously left out of strength science, and for years those of us who trained were following advice built for male bodies. Now we have real guidance on structure, progression, and timing.
​
​But what if the "best" advice doesn't fit your actual life? It's well-supported that resistance training in the afternoon produces best results. Great! Unless your schedule doesn't allow for a midday gym break. Does that mean you skip strength training altogether? Of course not. You fit it in where you can.
​
​The "right" answer in research is a starting point, not a mandate. Trust yourself to adapt it.

Motivation follows action. Not the other way around.

We tend to believe we need motivation to get started. But motivation is unreliable. It shows up when it feels like it, and when it disappears (often by mid-January) we assume we've failed and move on to the next shiny thing.
​
​Here's the twist: motivation is more like a fair-weather fan. It shows up once you're already winning. It doesn't take much forward momentum to get it back on the team. Just the smallest amount of effort, backed by structure. Structure is reliable in a way your mood will never by.
​
​Two steps to get started:

Accept yourself, and expect more from yourself.
​
​We're drowning in self-improvement advice. Work on this, do more of that, less of the other thing. It's endless (and yes, the irony of adding to that pile isn't lost on us). And somewhere in the middle of all of it is the equally common advice to accept ourselves as we are, love our bodies, and embrace our flaws.
​
​At first that feels impossible. If you accept yourself as you are, does that mean you've given up on improving? No necessarily. When you're at peace with where you are right now, you can move forward without shame. You're operating from grace and compassion instead of fear. Fear and shame may get you started, but they run out fast. Grace and compassion are what keep you going when it gets hard, when you slip up, when you hit a setback.
​
​Take body positivity. The expectation is that you should love your body. Body neutrality can be a more honest landing spot for a lot of people. It's just a body, no moral judgment attached, grateful for what it can do, while still wanting to build more strength and stay healthy enough to maintain independence long-term. Acceptance and striving for improvement at the same time.

Back to that Buddhist koan: the goal isn't to resolve the paradox. It's to think critically, lean into your lived experience, and get comfortable living inside the tension.
​
​A paradox surfaces between what you've been told is best and what you actually know to be true for you. It gives you permission to go against conventional wisdom, experiment, and find your own way.
​
​As physicist Niels Bohr put it: " How wonderful that we have met with a paradox. Now we have some hope of making progress."
​
​Your quick win this week: Pick one paradox from this list that resonated. You don't need to resolve it. Just notice where the tension lives for you, and what it might be telling you.